Freedom of Information request on Moorside Nukiller Health Impact.

radiation-effects.jpg
This graphic is very conservative – it applies to a fully grown male – the impacts on women and children are greater.

 

Dear Director of Public Health Cumbria/ Chair of the Moorside Health Impact Assessment Group,

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST

We have written to you repeatedly, including via Tim Farron MP to ask: Do you believe, like the government, that “population mixing” is the cause of the acknowledged and well documented excess of childhood leukaemia near Sellafield?  Or do you agree with the co-discoverer of plutonium and uranium, Dr John Gofman that there is no safe dose of radiation?  Which do you think the government and the industry should take responsibility for and to warn the population about :
A) Population Mixing?
B) Cumulative Radioactive Emissions from existing and new reactors?  (as well as routine emissions, particles of plutonium discharged from Sellafield to the Irish Sea are routinely found on our beaches and in our estuaries- some hotter than anything found anywhere else apart from in the immediate vicinity of Chernobyl and Fukushima http://www.theecologist.org/news/news_analysis/2988776/killer_hot_particle_sellafield_coast_like_chernobyl_and_fukushima_exclusion_zones.html )
or

C) Both?

As an answer has not been forthcoming Radiation Free Lakeland request under the Freedom of Information Act sight of all documentation, minutes and notes arising from the Moorside Health Impact Assessment meetings, including the one on Tuesday May 3rd 2016

We look forward to hearing from you.

yours sincerely,

Marianne Birkby
Radiation Free Lakeland

Letter Below sent to Colin Cox, Director of Public Health Cumbria, via Tim Farron MP on 9th February 2016 following the one sent in May 2016.

Dear Tim Farron MP,

Last May 2016 we wrote to the Director of Public Health along with hundreds of other concerned Cumbrians asking the following questions:

A Government Committee recently said that “Population Mixing” caused by an influx of nuclear workers resulted in “a Mystery Virus.” They said this is the likely cause of increased leukaemias near Sellafield.  This view is rather undermined by the Sellafield workers having a Compensation Scheme for Radiation Linked Diseases.  There are higher incidences of many diseases in the vicinity of Sellafield including childhood eye cancers and Downs Syndrome.

Do you believe, like the government, that “population mixing” is the cause of the acknowledged and well documented excess of childhood leukaemia near Sellafield?  Or do you agree with the co-discoverer of plutonium and uranium, Dr John Gofman that there is no safe dose of radiation?  Which do you think the government and the industry should take responsibility for:
A) Population Mixing?
B) Cumulative Radioactive Emissions from existing and new reactors?

The reply we received back from Colin Cox, the Director of Public Health Cumbria was dismissive and we are still waiting for an answer to our questions:

“I am the Chair of the Moorside Health Impact Assessment Steering Group. Health Impact Assessment (HIA) is a rigorous approach to identifying and mitigating any health risks, and identifying and maximising any health gains, arising from this development. At its meeting this morning, the steering group agreed that the issue of population mixing will be considered within the overall HIA.

The HIA is due to be completed by the end of this year. I will not be making any public comment on this matter before this process is complete.  I hope this information is helpful.

Regards,

Colin Cox

Colin Cox Director of Public Health Cumbria County Council”
Sent Tue, May 3, 2016 3:45 pm

Given that John Woodcock MP insists that Moorside would bring over 20,000 jobs to Cumbria, a county with 4000 claiming either JSA or Universal Credit is this more of a threat than a promise?   It seems to us that whether the well documented increase in cancers is due to an influx of nuclear workers or radioactive emissions, this is a lose-lose situation with regards the health and safety of Cumbrians.

We have written to an acknowledged expert and member of government committees relating to Medical Aspects of Radiation in the Environment and Dr Paul Dorfman’s reply to us is below.

________________________________ From: Dorfman, Paul Sent: 13 June 2016 09:59 To: Subject: Re:  Population Mixing V Radioactive Emissions. Govnt want their cake and eat it?]
Dear Marianne
Thank you for your letter concerning the key issue of childhood leukaemia in Cumbria.   As you may know, I served as Secretary to the UK governmental scientific advisory Committee Examining Radiation Risks from Internal Emitters (CERRIE), where we reported on this issue. I am also currently an advisor on radiation risk to the Irish Government Environment Protection Agency (EPA), and am an advisor to the UK MoD on the dismantling of the laid-up UK nuclear submarine flotilla. In other words, I am an acknowledged expert on radiation risk.   Regards future risk of childhood ill-health in Cumbria – I, like you, am of the clear opinion that the acknowledged significant increase in childhood leukaemia in Cumbria is associated with radiation releases from nuclear power plant.   However, there is no question but that the view of the key UK governmental radiation risk scientific advisory body – the Committee on Medical Aspects of Radiation in the Environment (COMARE) – is that the Cumbrian childhood leukaemia excess is most likely associated with a ‘population mixing’. In other words, COMARE, and hence the UK government state that the Cumbrian childhood leukaemia excess is due to a novel virus brought in by a large number of construction workers which then goes on to infect a relatively isolated local population who do not have a defense against this virus.   In this context, the UK government must take responsibility for this view. Thus the UK government must inform the local community to expect a potential increase in risk of childhood leukeamia following the construction of the planned nuclear facility at Moorside.

Sincerely   Paul   Dr Paul Dorfman The Energy Institute University College London Central House 14 Upper Woburn Place London WC1HH 0NN +44 (0)7972385303  Founder, Nuclear Consulting Group http://www.nuclearconsult.com/ Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust Nuclear Policy Research Fellow

Last weekend in Workington we collected more signatures to add to the hundreds of letters already sent to the Director of Public Health in Cumbria to again remind him to reply to our questions.  We would be very grateful if you could pass this letter on to him with the following questions for which we are still awaiting a reply.

Which do you think the government and the industry should take responsibility for:
A) Population Mixing?
B) Cumulative Radioactive Emissions from existing and new reactors?

Yours sincerely

Marianne Birkby
Radiation Free Lakeland

 

Save

One thought on “Freedom of Information request on Moorside Nukiller Health Impact.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s